There are some fundamental philosophical assumptions that this edition of 7th sea appears to operate on which I feel the game is the worse for.

I would like to discuss these in hopes that works in progress may take note and pursue a more liberating avenue.  Allow me to first qualify, I absolutely and fervently agree that the goal of a Session is for every player to have fun, and a good experience.  I disagree that the avenue and approach provided in 2nd edition achieves this.